How to Combine Multiple Automatic Discounts on Shopify? [2025]

An e-commerce store owner is allowed to create and manage various automatic and discount codes. However, if you want to stack discounts on a purchase, you need to learn how to combine multiple automatic discounts on Shopify in this article.

Combining different promotions adds more shopping value to one order, giving your customers the impression of spending less and gaining more. This strategy will be extremely helpful in increasing your sales revenue and customer satisfaction.

What are you waiting for? Let’s get to work on activating high-performing discount combinations as soon as possible!

1. Shopify Automatic Discounts Combination Scenarios

Shopify’s internal discount tools allow merchants to create and apply multiple discounts to customer orders. This combination works for both automatic discounts and discount codes.

Each discount created falls into one of the following categories, depending on what it applies to:

• Product discount: Discounts applied to a single product, a group of products, or specific categories.
• Order discount: Discounts are applied to customer orders based on several cart conditions.
• Free shipping discount: Discounts that offer free shipping for qualifying orders.

The following table provides a few examples of possible automatic discount combinations that Shopify supports (Source: Shopify Help Center)

However, there are a few points to consider when using Shopify’s internal tools to create and combine multiple automatic discounts:

1. A Product discount cannot be combined with another product discount applied to the same products. This typically occurs when merchants try to combine a “Buy X, Get Y” discount with an automatic product discount.
2. If you combine the Product discount class with the Order discount class, all existing product discounts will be able to combine with every active order discount. This applies to all Shopify discount combinations mentioned above. Therefore, you need to carefully calculate the discount amounts to avoid over-discounting customer orders.
3. Only 25 automatic discounts or discount codes can be active at the same time.

2. How To Create And Combine Multiple Automatic Discounts on Shopify using Shopify Native Discounts?

This section will give you an overview of how Shopify combines automatic discounts using its integrated settings. Our quick and detailed guide shows you how to create and combine multiple Shopify automatic discounts using its default functionality.

Step 1: Visit your Shopify admin dashboard > Click Create discount > Amount off products/order.

Step 2: Select Automatic discount and name the promotion for in-cart and at-checkout display. Regarding the Discount value, choose between a percentage or a fixed monetary amount. It can be applied to specific products or collections, and the available purchase types include one-time purchases, subscriptions, and both.

Step 3: For the Minimum purchase requirements, select the minimum purchase amount or quantity of items as you wish.

At Combinations, refer to the table to decide which discount type you will combine this new one with. Here are 3 active product discounts that are combinable with yours.

Lastly, configure the start and end dates for the discount > Save discount > Publish.

Read more: Shopify Automatic Discount is not Working: Troubleshooting Tips

3. How to combine Buy X Get Y Automatic Discount with Automatic Product Discount?

In this automatic discount combination scenario, if a product is part of a “Buy X, Get Y” automatic discount and qualifies for multiple Shopify automatic discounts, only the highest discount will be applied to the product.

To resolve this issue, the only solution is to use a third-party Shopify app, as it works separately from Shopify’s internal discount tools.

Additionally, if you’re on the Shopify Plus plan, you can code your own function to handle this, which could be an option if you have a development team.

Our recommendation is to use BOGOS – a powerful Shopify promotion app that enables merchants to create “Buy X, Get Y” discounts and combine them with Shopify’s internal discount tools.

BOGOS makes running multiple Shopify automatic discounts easy. For example, if you’re offering “Buy pants and a shirt, get free socks,” the app automatically adds the free socks to the cart when the customer qualifies. 

At the same time, Shopify’s built-in discount can be applied to pants without any conflicts. Simply set up the Buy X Get Y offer in BOGOS and configure the product discount in Shopify – you can now offer both promotions at once effortlessly!

To visualize everything easier, I will show you the steps now.

Step 1: Navigate to the BOGOS.io App and Create a New Offer

• Go to your Shopify Admin Dashboard.
• Under the Apps section, click on BOGOS.io: Free Gift.
• Click on the Create Offer button to start setting up your discount.

Step 2: Choose the Offer Type

• Select Gift Offer.
• Click Start under the BXGY (Buy X Get Y) option.

Step 3: Set Up Basic Offer Information

• Enter the Offer Title (e.g., “Buy 2 Snowboards, Get 70% Off”).
• Set the Start Time and End Time for the promotion to specify when the offer will be active.

Step 4: Define the Main Offer Condition

• In the Main Condition section:
  • Specify the number of products required for eligibility. For example, set “2” for customers to buy 2 of a specific product.
  • Check the Multiply gifts with the number of products option if you want customers to receive more gifts when they buy more.
• Click Select Products to choose the specific products eligible for the discount.

Step 5: Add Sub-Conditions (Optional)

• To refine the eligibility criteria, click Add Sub Condition:
  • Specific Link Address: Customers can only access the gift by using a specific promotional link.
  • Customer Order History: Only customers meeting a specific purchase history can qualify.
  • Customer Tags: Target specific customer groups based on tags in your Shopify store.
  • Customer Location: Restrict the offer to customers from certain regions or countries.
  • Subscription Products: Apply conditions for subscription-based products.
• Click Add This Condition after choosing the sub-condition.

Step 6: Select Gifts

• In the Select Gifts section:
  • Choose the Gift Discount Type:
    • Percentage: Discount the gift by a percentage (e.g., 70% off).
    • Amount: Discount the gift by a fixed monetary amount.
  • Specify the number of gifts customers will receive (e.g., 1).
  • Click Select Gifts to pick the product(s) customers will receive as gifts.

Step 7: Configure Advanced Settings

• Add a Cart Message to motivate customers. Example: “Special Offer: Buy 2 ‘Archived Snowboards’ and get 70% off ‘The 3p Fulfilled Snowboard!'”
• Set Priority for this offer to control how it interacts with other discounts:
  • Higher priority offers take precedence if multiple discounts are eligible.
  • Check Stop lower priority to ensure no other discounts override this one.

Step 8: Save and Activate the Offer

• Review all the settings and conditions.
• Click Save to finalize the offer. The offer will now appear in your active promotions and be visible to customers based on the conditions you set.

Additional Notes:

• Testing the Offer: Make a test purchase to ensure the Buy X Get Y discount works correctly alongside the product/order discount.
• Monitoring Performance: Use the Analytics section in BOGOS.io to track the success of your campaign.

4. Benefits of Automatic Discount Combination For E-commerce

When store owners combine multiple automatic discounts on Shopify for promotional campaigns, it benefits their businesses and their customers. Here are some noticeable gains for both parties with this practice:

Benefits for merchants

• Increased sales volume:

When customers are eligible to receive more than one automatic discount on Shopify, they will be incentivized for larger purchases. This increases the overall sales volume since people are more inclined to buy more items.

For example, having qualified for the promotion, a customer can combine a buy one, get one (BOGO) offer with a percentage discount.

Read more: An Ultimate Guide on How to Increase Sales on Shopify?

• Higher average order value (AOV):

In addition to the boosted sales volume, the automatic discount combination motivates buyers to add more items to their carts. The more they spend, the more they save.

Not only does it help maximize their savings, but it also leads to a higher AOV.

• Enhanced customer loyalty:

Offering a wide range of combinable discounts can enhance your customer experience, as they feel they are receiving the best deal. This positive experience will enhance your customer loyalty, encouraging them to return.

• Improved conversion rates:

Combined automatic discounts make shoppers feel like their purchases are valuable. That is why they are more likely to complete the order, reducing cart abandonment and improving overall conversion rates.

• Positive brand perception:

A merchant who enables flexible discounting is often perceived as customer-friendly. They will likely refer your brand to other people, increasing their brand reputation on the market.

Benefits for customers

• Better shopping value:

By combining discounts, online shoppers spend less but gain more, forming a perception of better shopping value. This makes them more satisfied with the purchase.

• Increased purchase motivation:

If customers are aware that they can combine Shopify multiple automatic discounts, they might be compelled to buy items they were hesitant about. In general, they see the overall cost as being more favorable.

• Simplified checkout process:

The checkout process is simplified since buyers needn’t worry about which discounts are applicable or having to input multiple discount codes manually. They can enjoy the promotions automatically as the system detects order qualifications.

5. Best Practices For Shopify Multiple Automatic Discount Combination

Take a look at some of our tips and strategies to combine multiple automatic discounts on Shopify to maximize your promotional efforts and achieve the best results.

Prioritize discounts based on value.

If you want to monitor which discounts are most likely to apply among multiple offers, set up specific conditions for your promotions, such as product-specific discounts or a minimum purchase amount.

Then, build a discount hierarchy by identifying which offers bring the most value to your buyers. Prioritize these discounts over others when planning your promotion strategy.

Use discount codes for more flexibility.

Aside from the automatic discounts, you can choose to combine them with discount codes for additional flexibility. For example, customers can enjoy an automatic BOGO promotion and still enter a 15% off code at checkout.

To encourage customers to use these discount codes, promote them on your website, via social media, and email campaigns.

Leverage bundles and upsells

When customers purchase a combination of related or complementary products, group them into bundles in advance so they will be triggered as an automatic discount.

Plus, you can enable in-cart upsells with discounts when certain items are added to the cart. For instance, the buyer can receive an extra discount or add a related product.

Limit discount duration.

Limited-time discounts work brilliantly to motivate quick purchases and reduce the chance of customers waiting for a better deal. This tactic creates a sense of urgency that compels them to grab the offer immediately.

Plus, you should regularly change your discount offerings. This keeps them engaged and prevents customers from always expecting the same deals.

Monitor and adjust the discounts.

Whether you use Shopify’s native features or a third-party app, they both have analytics systems to monitor the performance of your discounts. Additionally, try A/B testing to see how different discount strategies work with your target audience.

After that, adjust your work based on what is driving the most sales and customer engagement.

Prevent discount abuse.

Multiple automatic discount combinations may result in discount abuse. Merchants can prevent this by limiting the number of times a discount can be applied to the same item or used by the same customer.

Also, clearly define which products or collections are not included in your discounts. This helps avoid unintended large discounts for your customers.

8. Conclusion

Is it not so much of a challenge to combine multiple automatic discounts on Shopify?

Merchants are allowed to combine product, order, and shipping discounts to create various combinations and increase customer engagement. Not only does this tactic help grow your business, but it also brings better shopping value for your customers.

If you find that using Shopify’s built-in features is limiting, try a third-party app for a more advanced setup and smart discount combinations. Remember to follow our best tips to manage these offers effectively and maintain control over the margins.

9. FAQs