6 Popular Free Gift Promotion Strategy for Shopify: Boost Sales, AOV, and Customer Loyalty

It’s Charlie from BOGOS team, a robust Shopify app used to run the most successful promotions on Shopify.

In recent years, working as CMO of BOGOS, I have had the good fortune of working with thousands of merchants, from indie brands to high-growth teams. Here’s one truth I keep coming back to:

An intelligent free gift promotion strategy is superior to discounting. Every. Single. Time.

Take the thousands of brands that came to us post-iOS 14, when paid ads lost their edge and CACs spiked. Instead of pouring more money into ads, they changed direction: “How can we convert better, without discounting our product’s worth?”

That’s where free gift strategies stepped in — and the results speak for themselves: 41% conversion lifts, 2X AOV bumps, and long-term customer retention.

Stories such as this aren’t rare. That is what we see on BOGOS every week. In this guide, I will deconstruct the six best free gift promotion strategies our merchants employ to drive more sales, lift AOV, and/or retain customers, which I can assure you do not involve any hacks or gimmicks, just what works. Let’s see. 

Why Free Gift Promotion Strategy Works — From Psychology to ROI 

One thing I’ve seen across all verticals — from DTC cosmetics to enterprise retail — is that free gift promotions are effective because they satisfy a core psychological need: the need to feel rewarded. 

The true impact lies in perceived value. When customers believe they’re receiving a meaningful bonus, they’re far more likely to complete a purchase and come back again.

And yes, research backs it up. A 2019 study on ResearchGate shows free gifts boost “transaction utility,” making customers feel they’ve received more value, especially with thoughtful or useful items. A Retail TouchPoints survey adds:

• 90% of customers are more likely to repurchase after receiving a free gift
• 65% share their experience online

But beyond the studies, we see this every week at BOGOS. Merchants use free gift offers not just to lift conversion rates, but to build deeper loyalty, stronger brand affinity, and long-term retention. In fact, despite being a multi-promotions solution, most of BOGOS users still use Free Gift as their main promotion tool – during Mother’s Day 2025, 83% of BOGOS users chose free gift promotions as their primary promotion strategy.

So, how do you do it right? Let’s break down the six strategies that deliver — again and again.

Product-Based vs Cart-Based: 6 Free Gift Promotions That Convert

After analyzing thousands of promotions, we’ve discovered a simple truth: not all free gift strategies are designed to perform effectively. 

At BOGOS, after building and optimizing campaigns across industries — from skincare to electronics — we’ve found that the most effective strategies consistently fall into two core categories:

• Product-Based Triggers (e.g., Buy X, Get Y)
• Cart Value-Based Triggers (e.g., Spend $X, Unlock a Gift)

These two trigger types form the foundation of six high-impact strategies used by top Shopify merchants. Each is designed to drive conversions, lift AOV, and move inventory — all without devaluing your products through discounts.

#1 Product-Based Free Gift Promotion Strategies

Product-based triggers are one of the most reliable levers for driving action, especially when you want to grow sales without discounting your bestsellers.

Buy X, Get Y (BOGO)

Among the 6 free gift strategies we recommend most often at BOGOS, Buy X Get Y remains one of the most effective, low-lift ways to boost conversions and AOV.

It’s more flexible than just “Buy 1, Get 1 Free.” Any offer where customers unlock an extra item — either free or discounted — falls under this structure. Popular variations include:

• Buy 2, Get 1 Half Off
• Buy from Collection A, Get a Gift from Collection B
• Buy a specific product, get a complementary freebie

As long as the customer’s purchase unlocks an extra item, it falls under this strategy. BOGO is simply one specific (and popular) version of Buy X, Get Y.

This type of gift with purchase promotion works well because it makes customers feel they’re receiving more value, not just paying less. It’s especially useful when you want to:

• Promote specific products
• Launch new items
• Clear out old stock
• Encourage customers to spend more

To make BOGO or “Buy X, Get Y” work well for your Shopify store, keep these points in mind:

• Pair logical products (e.g., serum + mask)
• Make the offer visible on all devices
• Show it early — on product pages and in cart
• Set quantity limits to protect margins

At BOGOS, we’ve made this process effortless for over 50,000 Shopify merchants. Our app lets you set custom rules for any Buy X, Get Y offer in minutes, display eye-catching gift banners or sliders, and auto-add free items to carts when conditions are met — no coding required. 

With advanced targeting, you can personalize offers based on customer location or order history, while real-time analytics let you track and optimize performance. Backed by a 4.9-star rating from 2,200+ reviews, our BOGOS app has powered results like 8X revenue growth for beauty brands and €300K in BFCM sales for others.

That said, watch out for common pitfalls:

• Offering too many gifts (confuses shoppers)
• Poor mobile UX (kills visibility)
• Burying the offer in small print

Whether you’re running a holiday sale or a product launch, Buy X, Get Y is your go-to move. And with BOGOS, it’s never been easier to execute.

Free Gift with Every Purchase

If your goal is to turn first-time shoppers into repeat customers, few strategies work better than offering a free gift with every purchase. It’s simple, scalable, and delivers consistent results, especially for new stores or campaigns focused on brand awareness.

One BOGOS merchant, Heliocare UK, a sun protection brand operating in the competitive beauty space, implemented this approach with precision. They offered a free sample — such as the Heliocare 360° Advanced Body Gel — with nearly every order. The result? A 20% increase in AOV within two months, along with higher return rates and more repeat orders. 

To execute this effectively:

• Choose low-cost, high-perceived-value items like samples or branded postcards
• Auto-add the gift to the cart — reduce friction, increase delight
• Promote the offer clearly on your homepage, product pages, and in-cart

The psychology is simple: a small, relevant gift makes the customer feel valued. It also creates a moment of positive surprise, which often leads to better reviews, stronger loyalty, and higher LTV.

For brands entering a crowded market or seeking to establish trust quickly, this strategy is a powerful first step.

👉 For a Shopify store owner, I have broken down everything you need to know on How to Implement Free Gift With Purchase on Your Shopify store in this guide: How to Add Free Gift With Purchase on Shopify? [Last Updated: April 2025]

#2 Cart Value-Based Free Gift Promotion Strategies

These promos unlock when the total cart value hits a certain threshold. Ideal for increasing AOV and nudging customers to spend more.

Tiered Free Gift Promotions

Tiered free gift promotions are one of the most effective ways to increase AOV by offering increasingly valuable rewards as customers spend more. The more they add to their cart, the better the gift.

The goal is to increase AOV, and it’s ideal for stores with a large product catalog or a loyal customer base. One BOGOS merchant in the cosmetics and perfume niche, Glam42 from Israel, used tiered free gift promotions to tackle the challenge of scaling sales across thousands of products. 

With BOGOS, they set up tiers like a gift bag for spending ₪199 on specific brands and a premium gift set for over ₪499, automatically adding rewards to carts. This strategy drove customers to spend more to unlock better gifts, resulting in an incredible 800% sales boost from 60K to 500K per month, alongside a 22% increase in AOV.

To set this up, you can structure it with clear tiers. For example:

• Tier 1: Basic thank-you gift (e.g., sticker, sample) for any purchase
• Tier 2: More valuable gift (e.g., travel-sized product) unlocked at $50
• Tier 3: Premium reward (e.g., full-sized item or exclusive bundle) unlocked at $100

You should display a progress bar in the cart to show customers how close they are to the next tier, creating excitement and motivation. Here are some tips:

• Ensure each tier’s gift is noticeably better to encourage upgrades.
• Set thresholds based on your AOV for achievable goals.
• Use clear visuals to show progress toward the next reward.

This free gift promotion strategy has been a powerful tool for me during slower months, consistently boosting cart values with minimal extra effort.

Time-Limited Free Gift Campaigns

Another effective approach is time-limited free gift promotion campaigns, designed to create urgency and align with seasonal demand. These are perfect for major sales events like Black Friday Cyber Monday (BFCM), Valentine’s Day, Father’s Day, or product launches. 

To execute this, you can build a sense of scarcity by making it clear that the offer is temporary. Add a countdown timer to your homepage and product pages, and promote the campaign across emails and social media. 

For instance, during BFCM, offering a free holiday-themed gift for orders placed within 48 hours can drive significant sales spikes. You should focus on these elements:

• Use bold timers or banners to emphasize the deadline.
• Tie the gift to the season or event for relevance.
• Send reminder emails a few hours before the offer ends.

This strategy has been invaluable for me during peak shopping seasons, cutting through the clutter and prompting customers to act quickly.

Spend $X, Get a Gift

Moving forward, the Spend $X, Get a Free Gift strategy is a great way to increase AOV by encouraging customers to cross a specific spend threshold. This is best suited for stores with broad catalogs and mid-range pricing. 

One rule of thumb is to set the threshold around 20–30% above your AOV. According to digital marketing consultant Aaron Zakowski, setting the threshold at about 30% higher than your AOV (or modal order value) makes the goal feel attainable to most customers, thereby boosting overall revenue without risking cart abandonment. For example, if your AOV is $45, you can aim for a threshold of around $60 and offer a gift like a trial kit or mini bundle.

To apply this, you can select gifts with high perceived value but low cost, such as a sample set or a small accessory. Ensure that the offer is clearly advertised on product pages and in the cart, so customers know what they’re aiming for. You should consider these points:

• Set the threshold slightly above your AOV for a realistic stretch.
• Select gifts that hold value for the customer.
• Show progress in the cart to encourage additional spending.

Pairing this with other promotions, like buy one get one free promotions, can provide multiple incentives for customers to spend more, and it’s often a winning combination for me.

Free Shipping as a Gift-Based Incentive

Finally, let’s look at free shipping as a gift-based incentive. The objective is to boost AOV and reduce cart abandonment by rewarding higher spend with free shipping. This works especially well in markets like the U.S., Canada, or the EU, where customers are sensitive to extra fees or expect free shipping. 

To implement this, you can set the free shipping threshold just above your AOV. Combine this with cart progress bars to show customers how close they are to unlocking the “gift,” nudging them to add more items. 

You should also consider pairing it with a small bonus item, like a free sample, to create a double incentive. This approach once reduced my cart abandonment rate by nearly 20%. 

Here are the best practices:

• Phrase free shipping as a reward to enhance appeal.
• Set the threshold slightly above AOV to encourage larger carts.
• Use progress bars to visually motivate customers.
• Pair with a small gift for an added incentive.

This strategy has been a cornerstone for me in competitive markets, addressing a key customer pain point while driving up order values.

5 Real-World Wins Using Free Gift Promotion Strategy

I’ve had the privilege of supporting countless Shopify merchants over the years, and  I know the power of learning from the best. Below are five standout case studies that demonstrate how these strategies work in practice, with key takeaways to help elevate your store to some extent.

1. Starbucks – Loyalty That Turns Spending into Rewards

Strategy Used: Spend $X, Get a Gift (via point-based redemption)

When it comes to loyalty programs done exceptionally well, Starbucks is the first brand that stands out to me. The Starbucks Rewards program enables users to accumulate Stars (points earned with every purchase), which can be redeemed for complimentary drinks, snacks, or merchandise. The mobile app plays a critical role, enabling customers to pre-order, pay, and track rewards effortlessly.

Results:

• 40% of total sales are attributed to the Rewards program
• 71% of app users visited at least once a week
• 19.4M+ members

Takeaway: While it’s not a traditional gift-in-cart setup, the psychology is the same: reward loyal behavior with something tangible. For Shopify merchants, this model works great with point systems or gift tiers tied to spending milestones.

2. L’Oréal – Product Sampling with Time-Based Campaigns

Strategy Used: Free Gift with Every Purchase + Time-Based Gifting

L’Oréal has long mastered the art of combining product sampling with time-sensitive promotions to build hype and drive velocity.  

For the launch of its Elvive shampoo line, L’Oréal distributed 16 million free samples across the UK, supported by a high-frequency advertising campaign. In Malaysia, the brand hosted a 12-hour virtual beauty festival that featured giveaways, limited-time offers, and real-time customer interaction through chat. 

Results:

• One month’s worth of sales generated in 24 hours
• 17,000+ active chat sessions during the event
• 12% post-engagement rate
• Daily average sales quadrupled

Takeaway: Time-limited free gift promotions can create a sense of urgency and excitement, especially when tied to product launches. Whether it’s samples or exclusive items, giving customers a reason to act now can significantly boost short-term sales.

3. Dropbox – Freemium Incentives That Drive Virality

Strategy Used: Free Gift with Every “Signup” (via digital rewards)

Dropbox’s approach is a standout for anyone focused on innovative growth in the digital space.  Upon sign-up, users receive 2 GB of free cloud storage. Additional space is awarded for inviting others or sharing Dropbox on social media. 

This referral model turns each user into a potential acquisition channel, significantly reducing the need for paid ads. It’s a scalable way to give value upfront while encouraging users to promote the service in exchange for more “gifts.”

Results:

• 100K to 4M users in 15 months
• Referrals drove most growth
• Conversion rate to paid: 1.6%–4%
• Recognized by Harvard Business School as a model for viral growth

Takeaway: A free gift promotion doesn’t have to be physical. If you sell digital products, memberships, or downloads, think of what low-cost digital item you can offer upfront to get people in the door and coming back for more.

4. McDonald’s – Free Toys That Drive Family Loyalty

Strategy Used: Free Gift with Every Purchase

Since 1979, every Happy Meal has included a free toy, often tied to major movie franchises or trending characters. These toys create excitement for kids and influence family dining choices. By regularly refreshing its toy lineup, McDonald’s keeps customers coming back, turning a simple meal into a collectible experience.

Results:

• McDonald’s distributed 29M step counters during a 9-day Happy Meal promotion in August 2016, averaging 3.2M Happy Meals per day
• 14.6% of all McDonald’s orders during that period were Happy Meals
• The promotion generated an estimated $10M in revenue per day

Takeaway: The consistency and collectibility of the gift matter. For Shopify merchants, rotating gifts monthly or tying them to cultural moments (e.g., holidays, movie releases) can keep your store feeling fresh and build repeat visits.

5. H&M – Influencer Gifting That Scaled Brand Reach

Strategy Used: Free Gift with Every Post (contra gifting for UGC and reach)

The brand launched 9 targeted gifting campaigns, seeking influencers with over 20,000 followers across various niches (fashion, lifestyle, luxury, and parenting). Using the #gifted platform, they streamlined the manual process of finding, contacting, and managing influencer relationships. 

The platform’s geo-targeting and contra-gifting features helped H&M quickly match creators to specific campaign goals, including event attendance and product seeding for items like a new pleather skirt. Over 1,000 influencer applications were received, resulting in a large volume of UGC content across social channels.

Results:

• 56 influencers posted
• 3M+ followers reached
• High volume of UGC: photos, reels, and short videos

Takeaway: Gifting isn’t just for customers. It’s a powerful tool to activate content creators and grow reach organically. If your goal is visibility over direct conversions, this strategy can pay off, especially when paired with UGC-friendly products.

💡 You might want to read: 8 Creative Gift with Purchase Ideas and Successful Campaigns

Expert Tips From BOGOS to Maximize Your Free Gift Promotion Strategy

Before you launch your next campaign, here are five principles we see across the most effective free gift strategies, based on thousands of promotions across Shopify.

• Prioritize clarity over cleverness. The best-performing offers are simple, direct, and easy to grasp in two seconds or less.
• Choose gifts that feel intentional. Relevance beats convenience. A well-matched gift builds trust — a random one weakens it.
• Promote everywhere your customer interacts. Product page, cart drawer, checkout, post-purchase email, and social. Visibility drives uptake.
• Tie gifts to strategy. Want to launch a product? Move excess inventory? Increase return rate? Your gift should serve that goal.
• Think of your gift as a marketing asset, not a sunk cost. Done right, it pays for itself many times over.

Bonus Insight: Use “$0” — not “Free.”

According to a 2020 study named “Is $0 Better than Free?”, consumers respond more favorably to gifts labeled as “$0” than “Free.” Why?

Because “$0” subconsciously reminds people of what they’re saving – the cost they avoided. In contrast, “Free” makes them focus more on just receiving something. The study even found that this $0 framing works better for price-sensitive shoppers and personal purchases, where savings feel more personal and urgent.

Final Words 

In this blog post, I’ve broken down free gift promotion strategies that have worked wonders for boosting sales, raising AOV, and creating loyal customers among Shopify merchants. If you’re looking to put these ideas into action without any stress, I recommend trying BOGOS.io. It’s an easy-to-use app that helps you set up everything from BOGO to tiered gifts and spend-based rewards with just a few clicks, delivering strong results with minimal effort. See you in my next post!

FAQs