We know how tough it is to make your voice heard during the chaos of BFCM, where every brand is fighting for a click. The problem is that endless discounts can devalue your products and attract one-time bargain hunters. 

To counter this, we advocate for a more personal touch: a free gift that makes your customers feel truly appreciated. Follow along as we break down five powerful GWP concepts that not only drive sales but also foster a stronger, more loyal customer base.

5 Free GWP ideas proven to boost sales this BFCM

A smart gift with purchase can do what discounts alone can’t: excite, surprise, and deepen your customer’s connection with your brand. Below are 5 practical ideas you can adapt to maximize sales this BFCM.

1. High-perceived value, low-cost gifts

High perceived value, low cost gifts work because they give customers the feeling of receiving something “premium,” while costing your brand very little to fulfill. This category shines during BFCM, when every other store is shouting about discounts. A free mini or bonus digital perk makes your promotion feel different and memorable.

Some situations where these gifts make the most sense include:

• You want to increase AOV without discounting your core product line.
• Your products have strong repeat-purchase potential, so a free sample can hook future sales.
• You’re expecting heavy order volume and need a gift that won’t strain operations.

They’re a perfect fit for:

• Beauty, wellness, food — where trial drives repurchase. Research has shown that sampling can outperform ads in prompting future purchases.
• Lifestyle brands — where branded merchandise (like totes or stickers) keeps your name visible long after BFCM ends.
• Digital-first businesses — where e-books, guides, or templates can be delivered instantly with zero shipping overhead.

Examples that work in practice:

• A skincare brand offers two travel minis when customers buy a full-sized cleanser. The minis drive discovery of the wider line and increase repeat order rates.
• A home goods store gives away a reusable tote for orders over $80. Unlike a discount, the tote keeps your logo out in the world for months.
• A coffee roaster adds a Brew Masterclass PDF with any grinder purchase. Because the gift is digital, it scales easily during a peak season.

Extra tip for merchants: Set your spending threshold strategically. A proven rule of thumb is to place it about 30% higher than your current AOV. For example, if your AOV is $65, set the free gift threshold at around $85. This encourages customers to add an extra item to their cart while still protecting your margins.

2. Perfect pair gifts that complement the purchase

Perfect pair gifts are add-ons that directly support the main item a customer buys, making them feel like they’re walking away with a complete set. During BFCM, this tactic reduces buyer hesitation. Instead of wondering “Will I need to buy something else later?”, customers know they’re fully equipped from day one.

These work especially well when:

• Your products have obvious complementary items that make usage easier.
• You want to reduce returns or support requests by ensuring customers have everything they need.
• You’re selling higher-ticket products where a small accessory can tip the decision to “yes.”

Best-fit brands include:

• Electronics and gear that require maintenance or setup accessories.
• Fashion and footwear where care items (cleaners, protectors) that improve longevity.
• Fitness and outdoor where accessories enhance the experience.

Examples to illustrate:

• A sneaker shop includes a cleaning sponge with every order. It’s a small cost, but it keeps customers happy and extends product life.
• A phone accessories store gives a free desk stand when someone buys a new case. The stand makes the main purchase more useful.
• A yoga brand pairs a mat with a carry strap so first-time buyers feel ready to start right away.

And here’s the strategic angle: pair gifts don’t just improve the purchase experience, they can reduce refunds. For example, camera retailers have long used “starter kit” bundles with lens cloths or straps, not only to sweeten the deal but to lower the chance that beginners feel unprepared and send the product back.

3. Mystery gifts

Mystery gifts work very well as a free gift with purchase during BFCM. They turn a normal checkout into a small game. People are already moving fast and scanning many offers. A secret bonus gives them one more reason to cross your spending goal. It also helps you clear small or extra items without putting a big discount on them. When shoppers feel they got more than expected, they talk about it, which brings new traffic while the sale is live.

Some mystery gifts you can use:

• Coffee or tea taster packs. Example: one of three single-origin samples.
• Small branded keepsakes. Example: enamel pin, sticker set, key clip.
• Care or setup items. Example: sneaker sponge, lens cloth, cable tidy.
• Seasonal treats. Example: limited winter spice blend, holiday candle tin.
• Kids and hobby surprises. Example: random mini figure, surprise washi tape.

Mystery gifts are the best fit for

• Brands with many small SKUs that are easy to ship and easy to pick.
• Beauty, wellness, food and drink, stationery, toys, lifestyle.
• Stores that want a higher AOV without touching core prices.
• Teams that can pack at scale and need a gift that does not slow the line.

Tips for making it work:

• Always show customers the minimum value they’ll get. For example: “Mystery gift worth at least $15 is free with orders over $80.” That way, people know they’re not getting something cheap.
• Mix your stock wisely. Use mostly low-cost items, sprinkle in a few mid-range, and add one or two special pieces. This balance protects your margins while still keeping the excitement alive.
• Use visuals without spoiling the surprise. Show silhouettes, blurred photos, or a group shot with the caption: “You’ll get one of these — but which one?” That keeps curiosity alive while still setting expectations.
• Rotate surprise items mid-campaign. Swap in 1–2 new products halfway through BFCM weekend to keep excitement going. Announce the update in your email or IG Stories to spark fresh engagement and repeat visits.

4. Limited-edition gifts 

Limited-edition gifts are free items that exist only for a short time, usually made just for BFCM and never offered again. They’re not part of your regular product line, which makes them feel more special. For shoppers, that kind of exclusivity adds emotional weight. 

Some limited-edition gifts you can offer:

• Holiday-exclusive products: A candle brand can give a mini version of a scent that’s only made for BFCM, like “Spiced Plum & Cedar.”
• Custom-designed merch: A coffee shop could offer a branded enamel mug with “Black Friday 2025” printed on the bottom — never to be sold again.
• Limited-run prints or packaging: A beauty brand can gift a full-size product in special-edition holiday packaging, available for just one weekend.
• Collaboration pieces: Partner with a small artist or brand to offer a co-branded sticker pack or pouch that’s only gifted during BFCM.

Limited-edition gifts are best fit for:

• Brands with a strong identity, loyal following, or collector culture (beauty, fashion, lifestyle).
• Product lines that already rotate seasonally or launch new designs often.
• Stores are looking to build long-term brand value instead of just chasing volume.

Tips for making it work

• Add a date or visual marker. A small detail like “BFCM 2025 Edition” printed on the gift makes it feel more collectible. Even subtly, it tells buyers: this is a one-time thing.
• Don’t make all the gifts at once. For example, if you think you’ll get 1,000 orders, you can prepare 800 gifts in advance. Then keep materials ready to make the last 200 only if you need them. That way, if sales are lower than expected, you won’t waste time or money making extras you don’t use.
• Hype the scarcity (without overpromising). Use lines like “Available this weekend only” or “Only while stock lasts — we won’t make more.” Avoid false urgency, but don’t be afraid to be firm.
• Save a few for your best customers. After BFCM, surprise your top buyers who didn’t shop during the sale by sending them one. This builds goodwill and shows that limited-edition doesn’t have to mean exclusive to just one moment. It can be a loyalty play, too.

5. Tiered gifts

Tiered gifts are free gifts that get better as the customer spends more. Instead of offering one gift at a fixed threshold (like “Free tote with $75 purchase”), you set multiple levels and each one unlocks a bigger or more valuable reward.

For example:

• Spend $60 → get a deluxe sample
• Spend $100 → get a travel-size product
• Spend $150 → get a full-size hero item

This works especially well. Customers naturally try to “reach the next level,” which pushes up average order value (AOV) without needing to discount your core products. It also makes big spenders feel seen and rewarded, not just treated the same as someone spending the minimum.

Some tiered gifts you can offer:

• Skincare: $50 = mini cleanser, $100 = travel-size serum, $150 = full-size moisturizer
• Coffee brand: $40 = sampler pack, $75 = branded mug, $120 = limited-edition holiday blend
• Kitchenware store: $60 = mini utensil, $110 = chef towel, $170 = premium accessory bundle

Tiered gifts are best fit for:

• Brands with products in different sizes or price tiers (beauty, food, kitchen, home goods)
• Merchants who want to drive higher cart values without offering site-wide discounts
• Stores that sell sets, collections, or naturally bundled items

Tips for making it work

• Use three levels max. More than three tiers get confusing. Stick to low, mid, and high — enough to create momentum without overwhelming people.
• Anchor your tiers to your current AOV. Let’s say your average order is $70. Then you might set tiers at $75, $110, and $150. This nudges people to stretch just a bit further each time.
• Make the difference feel worth it. The reward at each step should feel clearly better. Going from a sample to a travel-size is a real jump. From there to a full-size? That’s a win.
• Let shoppers see what’s coming. Use a progress-style visual (like a gift ladder) on the product page or cart. When people know what’s next, they’re more likely to add another item.
• Auto-add each reward as the cart qualifies. Don’t ask them to choose or enter codes. The smoother the experience, the better your conversion rate.

How to execute your GWP strategy for maximum impact?

Here are 3 steps that ensure your promotion works smoothly and delivers the maximum return.

1. Set the right threshold

To encourage customers to spend more, a good rule of thumb is to set the free gift threshold about 30% higher than your current Average Order Value (AOV). AOV is simply the average amount each customer spends per transaction. By setting the bar slightly higher, you motivate them to add an extra item to their cart to qualify for the gift, naturally boosting your revenue.

To give shoppers an extra push, you can:

• Use a cart progress bar with a message like, “You’re only $15 away from your free gift!”.
• Highlight the threshold directly on product pages to show shoppers which items will help them qualify.
• Add a floating banner or sticky announcement bar that updates in real time as the cart value changes.

2. Create urgency & scarcity

The fear of missing out (FOMO) is a powerful motivator for shoppers. You can leverage this by adding time or stock limits to your GWP promotion. Make sure to place these messages front and center on banners, product pages, and social media posts to amplify the sense of urgency.
Here are a few ways to do this:

• Time Limits: “Today Only” or “Offer ends in 24 hours.”
• Stock Limits: “For the first 200 orders” or “Limited quantity available.”
• Exclusive Access: “Early access for VIP customers only” or “Unlocks with qualifying spend.”

Countdown Timers: “Deal ends in: 02:14:36” displayed live on PDP and cart pages.

3. Make the experience smooth

This is the most critical step to ensure your GWP campaign is a success. A complicated shopping experience can frustrate customers and lead to abandoned carts. Your goal is to make the process of receiving the gift seamless and effortless for the customer.

Automate the process so that when a customer’s cart meets the required threshold, the free gift is automatically added to it. This not only eliminates errors but also provides instant gratification, making customers feel like they’ve truly gotten a great deal. To achieve this, you can use several specialized tools:

• Shopify Scripts: Available on Shopify Plus, lets you auto-add gifts and customize checkout. Flexible but needs coding.
• Dedicated Apps: Easier for most merchants. BOGOS.io Free Gift is one of the most popular choices, offering auto-add gifts and tiered rules without coding. Other apps like Qikify and Gift Box can add extras such as cart progress bars or gift pickers, depending on store needs.

Besides automation, ensure your promotion’s conditions are communicated clearly and transparently across your site to avoid any confusion.

Final thought 

This BFCM, we believe the best way to win is by making your customers feel truly special with a thoughtful gift, not just another discount. These ideas are designed to spark excitement and increase cart sizes while strengthening your brand’s relationship with shoppers. To deliver that flawless experience, we highly recommend the BOGOS app to automatically handle adding the gift, making the entire process a breeze.

FAQs